Justin Bieber and Selena Gomez first stepped out publicly as a couple at the Vanity Fair Oscars afterparty back in 2011, and since then, their relationship has taken more than its fair share of twists and turns. After years of on-again, off-again shenanigans, the two have decided to give things yet another try; in November 2017, it was revealed that Selena and Justin are indeed a couple again, leading to some conflicting feelings from fans of both singers.

Regardless of public opinion, these two clearly have a chemistry that keeps them from being apart for too long. In this case, it seems likely that Selena’s recent health scare — she underwent a kidney transplant over the Summer — was the impetus for her reconnection with Justin. As we wait to see what’s in store for them going forward, let’s look back at their cutest moments so far.

Selena and Justin kissed in Malibu during a 2011 beach walk.

They shared a kiss during a friend’s beach wedding in Mexico in 2011.

Things got playful for the couple during a May 2011 beach day in Hawaii.

Selena and Justin sat together during the Billboard Music Awards in May 2011.

They packed on the PDA during a Hawaiian vacation in May 2011.

Justin and Selena had a seaside smooch in Hawaii in May 2011.

Bauer-Griffin Online

Justin snapped pictures of Selena while vacationing in Mexico in December 2011.

Justin took Selena on a helicopter ride in Brazil in October 2011.